A pizza stone is a great way to get the crispy Neapolitan crust you're looking for without all the hassle of a regular pan. A pizza pan is also more versatile - you can use it for baking a frozen pizza, making bread, and even baking your favorite food! 

The main difference between a pizza stone and a perforated pizza pan is the structure and heat retention of the utensils. A pizza stone is made from a block of stone that mimics a wood-fired oven, whereas a perforated pizza pan is a pan made with holes for better air passage. 

So, which one is better, pizza stone or perforated pizza pan? Without any further ado, let’s jump right into the details!

Should You Get Pizza Stone Or Pan? 

Purchasing a pizza stone over a perforated pizza pan depends on your preference. While both produce great cooking results, they aren't the same. However, we recommend you get perforated pizza pans for the best performance. 

Choosing a pizza pan is best for those who love to bake their pizzas and prefer a high-quality baking surface. Each has benefits, and a pizza stone will work for you, too!

A pizza stone can heat up faster than a metal baking sheet because of its porous surface. The perforated surface draws water out of the dough while the pizza is baking, creating an extra-thick crust. 

Difference Between Pizza Stone and Perforated Pizza Pan

The most significant difference between a pizza stone and a perforated pizza pan is their thickness. A pizza stone has a thicker base, so it has more surface area to absorb heat. 

The perforations in a perforated pizza pan make them more durable than their counterparts. A pizza stone retains heat longer than a perforated pan. You'll also have a crispy crust with a perforated pizza pan. If your pizza stone smells, you must take immediate action.

A pizza pan with holes allows for even cooking and a crisper crust. A pizza baked in a pan without holes is more likely to be soggy. The holes also allow moisture to escape and avoid the crust. 

If unsure, try cooking the same pizza on a perforated pan and baking stone to see what happens! You might be surprised; there are some benefits to each!

Advantages Of Pizza Stone and Pizza Pan

Below are some of the best pointers to help you figure out the differences between a pizza stone and a perforated pizza pan. 

Moisture

One of the main advantages of a pizza stone is that it removes moisture from the pizza dough while baking. 

In contrast, a perforated pizza pan doesn't have this feature, but it can allow heat to enter the food while allowing moisture to escape. 

The key is to find one that works for your cooking style. The best option for you will depend on the type of crust you're after. However, if you're in the mood for authentic Neapolitan pizza. 

Thickness

Different steels can vary in thickness, so look at this factor when comparing the two. Typical pizza steel has a thickness of three-eighths of an inch or more. 

The thicker it is, the faster your pizza will cook. 

But make sure you read the manufacturer's instructions on pizza steel thickness. Thicker stones also cook more quickly than their thinner counterparts. It is essential to test each type of steel before purchasing one.

Baking Method

A pizza stone will be the best option if you cook your pizza in the oven. A pizza stone is made of porous stoneware that lets heat penetrate evenly and produce a crisp crust. 

It also allows moisture to escape so you won't have a soggy crust or bottom! The perforated pizza pan may not be suitable for your wood-fired grill, so a stone is the better option.

Crust Texture

While both pizza cooking trays are effective, the stone is the better choice for beginners. A pizza stone will help you achieve the crispy bottom crust in the shortest time.

Because it will hold more heat, you can use it in a wood-fired oven to achieve a wood-fired pizza flavor. While there are some advantages to both, the pros outweigh the cons.

The non-stick coating of a pizza pan makes it easy to clean and won't stick to the surface. They also heat up quickly and don't leave burned parts behind; they are easier to handle. 

Restaurants aim for a perfectly doughy crust and use coupe pans made of aluminum. There are many options if you're looking for the perfect pizza pan.

Meltability

A pizza stone's spiral design allows the pizza to melt the cheese evenly and crisp up the outer crust. This results in a crisper outer edge, but the center will remain soft and underdone. 

Another difference between the two types of cooking tools is their size. A pizza pan is smaller, but it's not as easy to clean. You must be sure to choose the right one for your kitchen.

5 Reasons to Use Pizza Pans

A pizza pan can make or break your final product. Choosing the wrong pan or baking screen can ruin your pizza. Using a pan with the wrong thickness can result in a burned and soggy crust.

Pizza pans aren't essential to making a great pie. They can save you time and money by not requiring you to buy pizza peels, bench flour, or semolina. And, unlike traditional pizza pans, you don't need to preheat your oven. 

Here are five reasons to use a pizza pan.

Heat Flow

Perforated pans allow heat to flow evenly throughout the pizza's crust, so it cooks evenly and doesn't end up chewy or soggy. 

The perforations on perforated pans are made of aluminum and are incredibly durable. But be careful to monitor your pan's heat. If it's too hot, it can make  your pizza soggy or burnt. Besides, a perforated pan will also be easier to handle than a smooth one.

Neapolitan Crust

Pizza pans help cook thin-crust pizzas. However, when compared to pizza stones, they are more expensive. But, the price difference is well worth it. 

You can use them for other dishes besides pizzas. A black stone will work just fine if you don't need sauce. This type of stone also prevents excess liquid during baking. The crust will get crisp and flaky faster than with a pizza pan.

Deep Dish

If you're baking a deep-dish pizza, you'll want to use a high-priced pan that prevents the crust from burning before the toppings finish cooking. 

You can bake deep-dish pizzas in dark pans, but you must be careful when cooking them. In addition, you'll need to monitor the temperature.

Heat Absorption

A dark-coated pan will absorb heat and reflect light so that it will cook more quickly. You can purchase a tin-plated aluminum pan if you want a lighter-weight pan. These pans are dishwasher safe and easy to clean.

Non-stick

The best pizza pans will be non-stick, which makes them easy to clean. A non-stick coating prevents food from sticking, which increases the pan's life. Non-stick pans also prevent food from sticking to the bottom. 

They also make the pizza easier to remove. And, they make it easy to reheat, too. So, you have a lot of reasons to use a pizza pan!

5 Differences Between Pizza Stone vs Oven Rack

If you have a pizza oven, you probably have wondered about the 5 Differences between a pizza stone and an oven rack. Both options cook pizza evenly and taste great, but which is better for your home? 

We've answered these questions and more in this handy guide to baking pizzas. Also, find out why some recommend using a pizza stone over an oven rack. 

Weight

First of all, consider the weight. Steels are heavier than stone and are much better at transferring heat. Steels also "throw" heat into the dough faster than ceramic baking stones. 

We have the solution if you’re looking for whether you can use Muenster cheese on pizza.

The resulting crust will rise higher and brown more quickly. Lastly, a stone will retain heat for longer, so your pizza will stay crispy and delicious! You can opt for a steel pizza rack if you're on a budget.

Crust Factor

Using a pizza stone is best if you want to get that delicious restaurant-style crust. It takes less time to cook than a pizza pan and has a wood-fired flavor. However, a pizza pan may be easier to use, another benefit. 

A pizza stone will also prevent moisture from collecting underneath the crust. If you're buying a pizza oven, read the buying guide before making a purchase.

Material 

A ceramic pizza stone holds heat more evenly than a metal baking sheet, which gives the crust a crisp bottom. 

However, a pizza pan is easier to clean and store than a pizza stone. You can use the same pizza pan in a conventional oven and a microwave. Find out the ways to clean pizza steel.

And you can also rotate them for even cooking. 

Durability

Pizza steel may be cheaper but is not quite as durable. Although durable and can yield a good pizza, it is more susceptible to thermal shock, making it prone to shattering if accidentally dropped or under excessive heat. 

Regarding pizza stone vs oven rack, in terms of durability, pizza stone will always be the winner. 

Conclusion

The differences between pizza stone and perforated pizza pan may be many. However, we hope our article has helped you find the pizza baking utensil made for your needs. Hence, till the next time, happy feasting and safe baking!

Our real Italian pizzas from Italy are handmade with all-natural high quality and fresh ingredients in Naples, Italy delivered to you, anywhere in the U.S. Click Here to Buy Now!